Foundation for Fair Civil Justice

 
 

 Quick Links to Web Resources

State Supreme Court Analysis

U.S. Tort Liability Index - '06 & '08

State Profiles

Essential Reference

Speaker's Resource State Tort Law Profiles
 

Winners Announced Today!

Wacky Warning Label Contest Winner Named

2009 Winners of the Wacky Warning Label Contest have been announced. Now in its 12th year, the internationally known contest is sponsored by the Foundation for Fair Civil Justice. Millions of people around the world are reading stories or watching television news reports about the contest and laugh at how silly the warning labels are. 

 

Bob Dorigo Jones, (right), who developed the contest, explained that behind these silly labels is a serious public policy concern—America’s out-of-whack system of civil justice.  The contest reveals how lawsuits and the fear of lawsuits have driven companies to spend millions on common-sense warnings.

 

This year’s winner is a submission from Steve Shiflett of Hampton, Georgia.  The label is attached to a portable toilet seat for outdoorsmen called “The Off-Road Commode” because it is designed to attach to a vehicle’s trailer hitch.

The warning label reads "Not for use on moving vehicles".

 

Click Here to watch the 2-minute video.

 

Other winners include: 

  • A wart removal product instruction guide that warns, “Do not use if you cannot see clearly to read the information in the information booklet.”

  •  A label on the underside of a cereal bowl warns, “Always use this product with adult supervision.”

  •  A small, 1” x 4” LCD panel warns, “Do not eat the LCD panel.”

  •  A bag of livestock castration rings warns, “For animal use only.”

Follow Bob and Wacky Warning Labels!

Read Bob's Book!

Read More Here

“Once a year, millions of people around the world get a collective laugh from our winners,” said Bob Dorigo Jones, contest creator and bestselling author.  “The truth is, this is no laughing matter.  Outrageous warning labels confirm that the American civil justice system is out of whack!  In today’s economy, Wacky Warning Labels demonstrate the tax we all pay for lawsuit abuse.”

 

“Legal reform is urgently needed to help propel America’s economic recovery." says Dorigo Jones.  "Companies need to be focusing on developing new products and jobs, not on defending themselves against frivolous lawsuits.

But today, the thickest section of any telephone book in the U.S.  is the section advertising the services of personal injury lawyers, and that is not a recipe for an economic recovery. For America to thrive, we need to expand the labor market, not the litigation market.”

 

“According to the Pacific Research Institute,” continued Dorigo Jones, “$589 billion would be saved per year for investment in new jobs and consumer spending if U.S. tort-cost levels were comparable in relative size with other industrialized countries.  This amount equals an annual "litigation tax" for a family of four of more than $9,000."  In its 2007 "Jackpot Justice" study, PRI points out that jobs, earnings, output, tax revenue, and population grow faster in top tort states than bottom, and tax rates are lower too.

 

Philadelphia Loses Another Two Maternity Centers -- Closings Climb to 19 Due to Malpractice Liability

The in early November of the Chestnut Hill maternity unit (featured left) brings to 15 the number of Philadelphia-area  maternity centers that have closed due to the high cost of medical malpractice insurance among other reasons.  Pregnant mothers in crisis may have to drive more than an hour in traffic to reach a maternity care unit.

 

Two additional suburban maternity centers have announced they are closing -- Central Montgomery Medical Center in Lansdale and Brandywine Hospital in Coatesville.

 

The American Medical Association (AMA) has labeled Pennsylvania's healthcare delivery system as an “extreme-level crisis”, citing shortages in key specialties including OB/GYN, neurology, general surgery, oncology, and radiology.

 

"The announced closing of the Chestnut Hill Hospital maternity ward is yet another casualty of an unreliable medical malpractice system.  Restoring reliability to justice, such as with special health courts, is essential to restoring the trust needed for a healthy system of health care," said Philip K. Howard (left), Common Good founder and chair .
 

“Pennsylvania is the poster child for the plaintiffs’ bar vision of America – sue the doctor, sue the hospital, and when they leave, support taxpayer-funded subsidies to hold onto the remaining cash cow,” said Dan Pero (right), President of the American Justice Partnership (AJP). 

 

Former U.S. House Speaker Newt Gingrich (left), founder of Center for Health Transformation, offered the following critique:  “Health justice reform can make all the difference in the world as it relates to the accessibility of high quality healthcare.  Physicians want to practice in states where they can have an open, trusting patient-physician relationship.  And, physicians do not want to practice in states which favor predatory personal injury lawyers over physicians and surgeons.”

 

Read Dec 16 Article by Philadelphia Bulletin

 

Read More About Pennsylvania's Humiliating Crisis

 

Report Documents the High Financial Cost to Business of Out-of-Control State Medical Liability Laws

"In its report, Medical Crisis: A Pocketbook Matter for Employers, the Foundation for Fair Civil Justice reveals the shocking statistics behind the health care crisis in our nation," said John Engler (below), President of the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) and former Governor of Michigan.

"CEOs, small business owners, and top executives will learn that patient access to health care directly affects the cost of employer-paid health insurance. When a hostile legal environment chokes the health care profession in a state, insurers raise premiums or simply stop providing coverage," continued Engler. 

"Here is the fact: States that have expansive medical liability laws on their books have driven doctors and healthcare facilities out of business through sky-high malpractice insurance rates and predatory tactics of the plaintiff’s bar,” said Dan Pero, President of AJP. “Without basic legal reforms that protect patients and provide relief for the health care community, patients suffer and businesses are left holding the tab.”

Read More and Download Full Report (Updated October 2008)
 

Audio Interviews 

Dr. Lawrence McQuillan

Pacific Research Institute

In this FFCJ exclusive interview, Dr. McQuillan joins FFCJ's Kristyn Shayon to talk about the newly released US Tort Liability Index: 2008 Report, and the updated methodologies used to assemble the two rankings produced by the study.

Listen to Interview

Attorney General Bob McDonnell

Commonwealth of Virginia

Virginia Attorney General Bob McDonnell joins Kristyn Shayon to talk about "the terrific tort climate" in Virginia. His common sense approach to the application of justice has helped give Virginia a top ten ranking in several major surveys and reports of all fifty states.

Listen to Interview

Senator Charlie Ross

Mississippi State Senate

In this interview, Senator Ross gives us the behind the scenes look at just how close Mississippi came to a complete breakdown of the civil justice system, and the ensuing campaign for comprehensive legal reform that involved significant efforts from the business, medical and legislative communities alike.

Listen to Interview

Op-Ed Articles

June 6, 2008

Global Warming, Cooling and the Paradox of Blame

Shannon Goessling, Southeastern Legal Foundation

May 14, 2008

Limiting lawsuit abuses lowers costs from litigation,
creates jobs in long run

John Engler, National Association of Manufacturers
& Lawrence McQuillan, Pacific Research Institute

March 20, 2008

No Class

John Sullivan, Civil Justice Association of California

February 28, 2008

'Reform' groups want voters out of the loop

Dan Pero, American Justice Partnership

Essential Reference

With Justice For All

Andrew Napolitano, of the FOX News Channel, moderates a lively debate between Dick Scruggs and Steve Hantler, FFCJ Chairman, about the pros and cons of legal reform and the activities of the plaintiffs' bar.

Essential Information Series

FFCJ speaks with key business leaders and state officials about the urgency of lawsuit reform at the state level and what is at stake for consumers, business and the future quality of life in America.

Click to Watch 

Click to Watch 

 
 

 

 

The Foundation for Fair Civil Justice mission is to educate, motivate and empower the public to support state liability reforms to end lawsuit abuse.   If you know of or have authored an article or report that deserves recognition among corporate and public policy leaders, please send an email to LegalReform@lawexec.com Original material © 2009 Foundation for Fair Civil Justice xx

Don't Let the Plaintiffs' Bar Trick You Like This!

 

 

Send this page to a friend! (click here)

 

Sign-up For Free Email Newsletter About Wacky Warning Labels and Liability Issues Affecting You!

Click Here!

 

Conversations With Barbour, Manchin and Hantler

Read About the Tangible Benefits of Legal Reform

 

CBS Evening News Highlights Medical Liability Crisis in PA

Click Here for Video

 

Employees in Pennsylvania? Listen to this!

 

Buy This Book!

Remove Child Before Folding

Read More Here

 

 Legal Reform Partners and Resources

Alabama Voters Against Lawsuit Abuse

American Enterprise Institute Liability Project

American Legislative Exchange Council

American Tort Reform Association

American Association of Managing General Agents

Associated Industries of Florida

Association of Washington Business

Association of Commerce & Industry of New Mexico

Business Council of Alabama

California Technology and Manufacturers Association

Center for Individual Freedom

Center for Legal Policy, The Manhattan Institute

Central California Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse

Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse of Houston

Civil Justice Association of California

Class Action Watch

Colorado Association of Commerce and Industry

Colorado Civil Justice League

Competitive Enterprise Institute

Council for Citizens Against Government Waste

Doctors for Medical Liability Reform

Federalist Society

Florida Chamber of Commerce

Florida Coalition for Legal Reform

Florida Justice Reform Institute

Georgia Chamber

Heritage Foundation

Illinois Civil Justice League

Illinois Chamber of Commerce

Illinois Manufacturer's Association

Iowa Association of Business and Industry

Kansas Chamber of Commerce

Kentucky Partnership for Commonsense Justice

Lawsuit Abuse Reform Coalition

Lawyers for Civil Justice

Point of Law, The Manhattan Institute

Manufacturers Alliance/MAPI

Michigan Chamber of Commerce

Michigan Lawsuit Abuse Watch

Michigan Manufacturers Association

Mississippi Economic Council

Mississippians for Economic Progress

Missouri Chamber of Commerce

Montana Chamber of Commerce

National Association of Manufacturers Fair Litigation Action Group

 New Mexico Alliance for Legal Reform

North Carolina Chamber

Ohio Business for Legal Reform

Ohio Chamber of Commerce

Ohio Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse

Ohio Manufacturers Association

Oklahoma State Chamber of Commerce

Overlawyered.com

Pacific Research Institute

Politically Active Physicians Association

San Diego Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse

Silicon Valley Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse

South Carolina Chamber of Commerce

South Carolina Civil Justice Coalition

Southeastern Legal Foundation

Texas Civil Justice League

Washington Legal Foundation

West Virginia Chamber of Commerce

Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce

 

 

 

 

 

Kristyn Shayon

Director, Communications

Foundation for Fair Civil Justice

404.228.3261

KShayon@lawexec.com