American Justice Partnership

Opinions/Editorials on the Case for Legal Reform

 
 

Choose one:

Invest in jobs or pay off personal injury lawyers

by

Robert B. Dorigo Jones

M-LAW

 

As appeared in The Detroit News, February 26, 2007

Michigan has been at or near the top among states with weak economies. Now the Michigan House is digging that hole a little deeper by approving a proposal that will chase more pharmaceutical and life-science jobs out of the state.

In other states, personal injury lawyers troll for customers on daytime television to assemble high-profit lawsuits against drug companies. You don't see those ads in Michigan because in 1996, state leaders reformed liability laws, creating a national model.

In Michigan, such a lawsuit requires evidence of actual fraud by drug companies. This prevents personal injury lawyers from second-guessing the federal Food & Drug Administration (FDA) over drug approval -- and swooping into our state with dubious lawsuits to make a mint off the companies that create our jobs.

Yet last week the Democratic-controlled state House approved a plan to open the floodgates to such lawsuits. It was an extravagant, post-election "thank you" to their supporters in the trial-lawyer bar.

If these laws go into effect, 10 years of unwarranted lawsuits will be let loose all at once on the Michigan court system. If the suits had merit, they could have been filed any time during the past decade. Part of the 1996 reform protects a citizen's right to sue.

But if the House rolls back reform, it's "anything goes."

These lawsuits won't simply be absorbed by deep-pocketed "big business." The cost will be passed along to the rest of us in the form of higher prices, lost jobs and missed opportunities as businesses choose to open elsewhere.

Money that could have been invested in Michigan's hungry economy will instead become lottery-sized paychecks to personal injury lawyers, who soak up more than 50 cents out of every dollar allegedly won "for the little guy" in these frivolous cases.

Urge your senators to preserve the common-sense legislation now in place. There is too much at stake: Around 540 pharmaceutical or life-science companies operate in Michigan. They employee 31,000 people and generate sales just under $5 billion--that's money that comes to our state and stays here.

Pharmaceutical and life-science businesses that chose to create jobs in Michigan know they can avoid the harassment by personal injury lawyers they are subjected to elsewhere. Michigan has led the way on this issue. Let's hold on to our advantage.

 

Columnist:

   

Robert Dorigo-Jones

President, M-LAW

248-449-2990

bdorigojones@mlaw.org

New Book by

Bob Dorigo-Jones

Remove Child Before Folding

Read More Here

 

 

Op-Ed article submissions should be made to Op-Ed@lawexec.com.

All articles must include contact information for the author(s) and only signed articles will be considered for publication.

 

 

If you know of or have authored an article or report that deserves recognition among corporate and public policy leaders, please send an email to LegalReform@lawexec.com.  Original material © 2007 American Justice Partnership.