American Justice Partnership

Opinions/Editorials on the Case for Legal Reform

 
 

 

Punitive Damages: California Project to Stop Super Shakedowns

 

 By John Sullivan

President

Civil Justice Association of California

 

Special to the American Justice Partnership

Signatures are being gathered in California for an ballot initiative to stop a major abuse of punitive damage law – lawsuits attempting to punish manufacturers even when they’ve follow the law in making their product.

 

These lawsuits might be termed “super shakedowns.” They are based on schemes to stir up public fear, play on animosity toward big business, and take advantage of vague punitive damage definitions to present a threat of a maxi-multi million dollar damage award and extort a huge settlement from a company that in fact has played by the rules.

 

The California initiative says simply that a company making a product that has received government approval or met government standards cannot be accused of bad behavior meriting punitive damages if the product later causes harm. People injured would still be compensated for their losses – it’s just the trial lawyers’ hunt for their punitive damage pot of gold that would be reined in.

 

If a company misleads regulators at any point during the approval and monitoring process, the punitive damage protection is lost.

 

Focus groups and polling tell us that when the proposal is explained to voters, and they hear arguments both pro and con, a solid majority support the idea. This is very similar to the responses we received in polling preparing for the successful 2004 campaign to enact California’s Proposition 64 (which stopped private lawyers bringing shakedown lawsuits under California’s unfair competition law).

 

Voters want to curb runaway punitive damage awards and stop the threat of punitive damages being used to shake down defendants – as long as there is a ‘safety net’ so those truly injured or harmed can have their day in court and recover compensatory damages.

 

The team that made Proposition 64 a winner is setting the stage for an election win to enact this important “government standards defense” proposal. A committee “Californians for Sensible Lawsuit Reform,” has been set up to raise funds and manage the campaign to enact this “Safer Products Initiative.”

 

The information below explains the problem, solution, path to a win in more detail.

 

 

To View information on Californians for Sensible Lawsuit Reform Click Here

 

 

 

John H. Sullivan

President

Civil Justice Association of California

Co-Chair

Californians to Stop Shakedown Lawsuits - Yes on Proposition 64

 

Contributor:    

John Sullivan

President

Civil Justice Association of California

1201 K Street,

Suite 1960

Sacramento, California 95814

916-443-4900

(f) 916-443-4306

cjac@cjac.org

 

 

 

Op-Ed article submissions should be made to Op-Ed@lawexec.com. All articles must include contact information for the author(s) and only signed articles will be considered for publication.

 

 

If you know of or have authored an article or report that deserves recognition among corporate and public policy leaders, please send an email to LegalReform@lawexec.com.  Original material © 2006 American Justice Partnership.